Mycotoxin Poisoning
I have had a very unfortunate and painful crash course on
mycotoxin poisoning. Don't know what that is? Neither did I, other
than hearing the word on the rabbit lists I am on, until my bunnies started
dying.
For the last 8 years, I have bought my rabbit food from Pet
Supplies Plus. They have always carried a brand called Double Duty and we
bought it 50 pounds at a time. Over the years, my bunnies have never had
any health problems and with the exception of new rescues coming in with illness
or my bunny with cancer, I have been very fortunate. In July 2002, Pet
Supplies Plus changed their brand of rabbit feed from Double Duty to Scarlet. We
bought a bag because the bunnies obviously still needed to eat! The
bunnies took to it with no problem but my husband commented that this new food
"looked" cheaper and lower quality than the other food. 6 weeks
after the bunnies started eating this new food, several of them suddenly started
getting sick. The first signs I saw were excessive drinking, messy butts,
runny eyes and runny noses. My first thought was "What the heck is
going on here?" "Why are my bunnies suddenly getting
sick?". My husband and I decided it was most likely the food since
that was the only thing that had changed in our environment. We removed
all their food and put it aside in a bucket. The next day, I found a feed
store about 25 miles from our house that carried Purina Rabbit Chow.
I took 2 of the sickest bunnies to the vet. She didn't
find any specific cause but put the bunnies on an antibiotic. Peanut was
the first bunny to die on 9/23/02 followed by Freckles on 9/24/02,
Vincent on
9/27/02, Daffy on 9/28/02, SweetPea on 10/3/02,
Big Bunny on 10/24/02, Snugglebunny
on 11/29/02, Calypso on 12/02/02 and Cocoa on 1/9/03.
You can see all my beautiful bridge bunnies and what signs and symptoms they had
by clicking here. We had several more vet trips and
many medicines later, the bunnies were still sick or dying.
After the first 2 bunnies died and 5 more were still sick, I
notified the pet store that I believe that the problem was most likely mycotoxin
poisoning and that I would be sending a food sample to the state veterinary lab to
find out for sure. They basically blew me off and told me to let them know
what I found out from the testing but that no one else had reported any
problems. I told them that most people have 1 or 2 rabbits and if they got
sick or died suddenly, they wouldn't have a clue why and wouldn't pursue it the
way I was.
Freckles's body was sent to the state lab in Columbus, OH for Necropsy
and when Daffy died, his body was also sent for testing. In the meantime,
I also filled a bag with the bunny pellets I suspected of being the problem and
I sent it off to the state lab in PA.
The necropsy results were 4 pages long
but boil down to the following:
Sections of cerebrum, cerebellum, brainstem, kidney,
lung, spleen, pancreas, liver, kidney, skin, stomach, large and small intestine
were examined.
- The section of kidney had one small lymphocytic
focus in the cortical interstitium
- The section of lung had a homogeneous,
eosinophilic material, edema, present in alveoli and the lung was congested.
- The section of cerebrum had mild
lymphoplasmacytic perivascular cuffing present in the neuropil in the
hippocampal region. One section of the cerebrum appeared to have a
focus of gitter cells and lymphoplasmacytic perivascular cuffing.
- Mild saponification was present in the adipose
tissue adjacent to the pancreas.
- The section of liver had a mild lymphoplasmacytic
infiltrate in scattered portal triads.
- The section of heart had a mild mononuclear
infiltrate in the epicardium and adjacent mycocardium.
- The section of skin was ulcerated and degenerate
and karyorrhectic neutrphils (heterophils). Ecsinophillic cellular
debris and bacteria in the site of ulceration.
- The lungs were severely congested and edematous. The
lungs were lightly firmer than normal.
- The changes in the lungs are highly suggestive of acute
pneumonia.
- The tissues were markedly autolytic
- Within the right war canal was
a purulent, yellow material. This material extended into the tympanic
bulla
To see complete necropsy results, click
here.
Results on the first food testing came back as follows:
Feed sample submitted contained 60.0 ppb Zearalenone
and 2.0 ppm Deoxynivalenol (vomitoxin or DON). Sample submitted was
negative for aflatoxins at levels > or = 5.0 ppb and T-2 at levels > or =
50.0 ppb.
Now I can't begin to claim that I really understand what all this all means
except that the food was positive for mycotoxins and my bunnies had a variety of
problems found upon necropsy with the most likely cause being those mycotoxins.
So now what...I called the Pet Supplies Plus again once I received the mycotoxin
positive results. Pet Supplies Plus
stated that they REFUSE to remove the food
from their shelves and said they have no intention of doing anything about
it. They told me to call the home office, which I did, and they told
me to call the distributor, which I did. Nobody seems to want to acknowledge this, even
with the lab proof I have.
On 10/25/02, I spoke with the State of OH
department of Agriculture and explained to them what has been going on and the
response from the pet store. The gentleman I spoke with (don't wish to
list his name here) was appalled at the reaction of the pet store and sent an investigator to the store
the following week. On 10/25,
I also bought a new bag of food off the pet stores shelves and sent it to the state
lab in PA for additional testing. I wanted to see if what the pet store
was still
selling was contaminated with mycotoxins. Interestingly enough, the
food on the shelves was in a completely different bag that what it had been
packed in since it first came into their store. Seems kind of strange to
me since they had told me they didn't intend to do anything about the food after
I reported it to them since they said that no one else had complained.
10/28/02 I got a call back from the
distributor for the pet store and he informed me that they do not feel
that there is enough evidence to prove that their food had anything to do with
my bunnies deaths or current health problems. Therefore, they intend to do
nothing about the situation or reimburse me at all for all my
expenses. I told him that he had not heard the end of me.
I took Cocoa to the vet again on 10/28/02 because he seemed to be
getting worse. Cocoa has had white stuff coming from his nose for a few
weeks. He has been on SMZ, Oxibendazole, Lincocin and several other
medications
but he has made no improvements. The vet said that the white stuff from
his nose would usually indicate pasteurella but he has no lesions which would
confirm that. His ears were fine and his lungs sounded good but he is down
to 2lbs from 2.5lbs. She started Cocoa on baytril and Pen-G on the hopes that we
might be able to get this cleared up.
During this time, Caly has been extremely sick. The vet
has tested for many things and not found any cause for the use of her limbs,
severe malnourishment and deyhdration. Caly's eyes, ears and nose have
remained clear and she showed no obvious signs of infection. I was syringe
feeding Caly twice a day in addition to sub-q fluids, baytril, Pen-G and
oxibendazole but there was still no improvement. Caly had a Rabbit
Complete blood panel done and her results were all over the board but didn't
point to any specific problem. To see Caly's blood results, Click
Here. My vet began contacting other vets and resources that either one
of us could think of.
My vet received the results from the 2nd sample of Scarlett food
that I sent to the State Veterinary Lab in PA. This time, they wouldn't
send the information to me so I had to have the vet fax it over. There was a
comments section and this is what it said.
Specimens are accepted through practicing
vets on behalf of owners of pet animals. We will offer consultation to you
in an effort to help solve your client's problems. Please relay these
results to your client. There is a rumor circulating among rabbit fanciers
that mycotoxins are causing problems among rabbits. I suspect that these
rumors originate from a non-veterinarian nutritionist. On several
occasions I have referred to colleagues whose practices are limited to
veterinary toxicology. They have no knowledge that rabbits are
particularly sensitive to any of the common mycotoxins. The history
provided by Ms. Palevsky suggests environmental problems resulting in or in
addition to some of the common pathologic problems of pet rabbits. She
refers to pathology reports but did not include them. The results of our
tests are included. None of these feeds are considered to have mycotoxins
in concentrations expected to be harmful to domestic animals. Also, for
future reference, we do not conduct testing on products for the
purposes of quality control on those products. If you, doctor, have any
additional questions, please don't hesitate to call.
The lab findings from the second set of tests on the food are
as follows: (To see the first results again, Click
Here.)
Feed sample Scarlet 1 contained 1.5 ppm DON on an "as fed" basis
Feed sample Scarlet 2 contained 2.0 ppm DON on an "as fed" basis
Feed sample Scarlet Treats (I always mixed it in with their food) contained .9
ppm Fumonisin on an "as fed" basis.
(From Cristina
Forbes) Test results reported on an "as fed" basis underestimates
the amount of mycotoxin contained in the samples. More accurate, more comparable
measurements are reported on a "dry matter" basis, with the moisture
content removed. Say a sample contains 10% moisture, you have to divide the
amount of mycotoxin measured by the dry amount of sample (100-10% = 90% or .9),
so:
1.5 ppm of DON "as fed" --> 1.5/.9 = 1.67 ppm of DON on a "dry
matter" basis
2.0 ppm of DON "as fed" --> 2.0/.9 = 2.22 ppm of DON on a "dry
matter" basis
0.9 ppm of Fumonisin "as fed" = 1 ppm of Fumonisin on a "dry
matter" basis
Now, I don't know if someone is paying off this lab to say that
mycotoxin poisoning is a rumor but every study I have read on the web talks
about it and its devastating effects in farm animals. I also find
it interesting that the same lab tested both food samples and did the testing
based on a dry matter method the first time but on an as fed basis the second
time. Information
I was given is that there is a distinct rift within the toxicology community
regarding how dangerous mycotoxins are. One group of toxicologists (primarily
those with ties to large agribusiness/farmers, who want their livestock just
healthy enough to make it to slaughter) maintains that animals can withstand
high
levels of mycotoxins, while the other group has observed, both in their research
and in the field, that much lower levels can cause significant damage to
animals.
As suggested by Cristina Forbes, my vet called Dr. Winston Hagler, Professor and Director of the Mycotoxin Laboratory at NCSU. His credentials can be found here:
http://www.cals.ncsu.edu/poultry/hagler.htm.
In any case, he says there is no way to tell 100% that it is mycotoxins but since they do compromise the immune system and the pathology and symptoms of the bunnies has varied without finding any definite
cause, the most likely cause would have to be the mycotoxins. This doctor did say he hadn't studied rabbits specifically but he knows
their systems are very
susceptible to the effects of mycotoxins. (See how this specifically contradicts
what the lab that did the testing said?) My vet wrote up a summary of that conversation and
sent it to me. This completes my documentation and proof that this rabbit food is the cause of my bunnies illness and deaths.
If you would like to see the contents of the letter my vet wrote, Click
Here.
Another friend of mine, Linda Ogawa Oleszko, who runs the
Michigan Rabbit Rescue, contacted the owner of some of the Pet Supplies Plus
stores. She apparently has had some interaction with him and he has been
very helpful to MRR. Linda explained the situation to him and the steps I
wanted to take (TV, newspaper etc..). Linda told me that he truly cares
about the animals and felt he would want to do the right thing. He assured
Linda that this food would be removed from the store and the manager would
contact me. I did not hear back from the manager but I have to believe the
food was pulled as he stated. This owner asked me to call his secretary to
send all of my documentation and the reasons I feel that this food is
responsible for the death and illness of my bunnies. I sent all the
information as requested and told the owner that I looked forward to a response
by 12/14/02.
On 12/4/02, I received a call from the distributor asking me to
remove this page from my site and any mention of their food and mycotoxins
because they feel that it is slander. I disagree and told them that I am
merely stating facts and that I use my site to educate people from what I learn
and that I absolutely would not remove this information. No where on this
site have I mentioned the name of the distributor nor the company he works for,
so I don't see how this can be slander.
There is no possible way to know who is responsible for the
mycotoxins. It could have left their place fine and was stored wrong
during transport or at the store. I won't say it left the company this
way, but the fact is, this food contains levels of mycotoxins that are dangerous
and lethal. When a meat company gets reports that the meat they have had
shipped out is causing people to get sick, the first thing they do is a massive
recall so no additional people will get sick. They don't point fingers or
refuse to take action, they act to stop the problem. When I made my
initial contact to the store, home office and distributor, I just wanted the
food pulled and tested. I only became "pissed at all of them"
when they all refused to step up to the plate and do the right thing. Why
do our animals not deserve the same rights that we do when food is suspected of
causing illness and death?
The last few months have been very difficult on me and my
family. It is physically and emotionally draining to watch helplessly as
your beloved fur babies keep getting sick and dying despite all your
efforts. When you are so tired that you just want to get into bed but you
have to bathe a bunny that can't stand on her own and change her diaper, feed
her and give her fluids and then still take care of all the other bunnies and
sick children and household things and you just can't imagine being able to do
this for 1 more day...but you do, because you have to. I hope that no one
else ever has to go through what we have been going through and I pray that I
don't lose any more of my beloved babies but I know that I have some still sick.
As I learn more, I will
continue to update this page.
I have received tremendous emotional
sand financial upport and notes from all of you out there. I have had people asking me
how they can help or offering me additional suggestions and possibilities.
I can't begin to tell you all how much all of your notes have meant to me and I
can truly feel your love and support. I am sorry if I don't respond to
your notes right away, but please know that I read each and every email but I
often don't have the strength to respond to everyone. Bless you all and
thanks for taking the time to read this page.
Excellent Links for more information on Mycotoxins:
Mold
and Mycotoxins in Rabbit Feed - This site is by Cristina Forbes PhD and is a
MUST READ! European
Mycotoxin Awareness Network Mycotoxins
in Corn (Many Rabbit foods include ground corn) Understanding
and Coping with Effects of Mycotoxins in Livestock Feed and Forage What
dairy farmers and vets need to know about molds and mycotoxins
|